Greece, New York – A tragic crash at a busy intersection in Greece, New York, has now claimed a third life, deepening the sense of loss felt across Monroe County.
Greece police confirmed Monday that Riesen Kimmerly, 25, of Hamlin, died from injuries she suffered in a two-vehicle collision on Jan. 17 at the intersection of West Ridge Road and Elmgrove Road. According to her obituary, Kimmerly passed away Saturday after spending days hospitalized with critical injuries.
Investigators say Kimmerly was stopped at a red light around 1 p.m. when her vehicle was rear-ended by a westbound pickup truck driven by Craig Cavallaro, 42, of Hilton. Cavallaro was pronounced dead at the scene. Kimmerly and her boyfriend, Tyler Underwood, 28, also of Hamlin, were rushed to Strong Memorial Hospital with severe trauma. Underwood died five days later, on Jan. 22.
Family members say the couple suffered traumatic head injuries and multiple broken bones. Kimmerly reportedly underwent surgery for a collapsed lung and a brain bleed. Their puppy, which was riding with them, also died in the crash—an added heartbreak that has resonated deeply with supporters.
Police say the investigation remains ongoing, and no additional details about the cause of the collision have yet been released.
“The Greece Police Department extends its deepest condolences to the families, friends, and loved ones of those who tragically lost their lives in this incident,” the department said in a statement, calling it an “incredibly difficult time” for all involved.
Kimmerly is being remembered as a vibrant young woman with a deep love for the outdoors. A Brockport High School graduate, she studied engine repair at Monroe 2–Orleans BOCES in Spencerport and was known for her adventurous spirit. Friends and family recall her passion for fishing, kayaking, horseback riding, and live music.
“Her warmth, kindness, and genuine nature allowed her to form deep connections with others,” her obituary read. “Her presence brought joy to many.”
As Greece continues to grieve, community members have renewed calls for driver awareness at high-traffic intersections. Local safety advocates note that rear-end collisions remain among the most common—and often preventable—causes of serious roadway injuries.
For now, the focus remains on honoring three lives lost and supporting the families left behind.
