A California cold case has taken a major turn after forensic DNA testing helped investigators identify a man whose remains were discovered in Foresthill more than four years ago, leading to the arrests of his wife and daughter.
The Placer County Sheriff’s Office identified the victim as Paul Wesley Fitzmaurice Jr., who was 73 years old at the time of his death. His wife, Georgia “Gwenn” Fitzmaurice, 75, and their daughter, Mary Fitzmaurice, 45, were arrested on November 17, 2026, in connection with his killing.
According to investigators, the case began on September 28, 2022, when a resident walking her dog discovered a severed human head inside a trash bag in the Todd Valley area of Foresthill, Placer County, California. Authorities were initially unable to establish the victim’s identity because of the condition of the remains.
Investigators pursued several identification methods, including forensic examination and searches of national DNA databases. However, those efforts initially produced no match.
A significant breakthrough came in January 2024, when detectives submitted DNA evidence to Othram Labs for forensic genetic genealogy testing. The laboratory developed a genealogical profile that helped investigators identify potential distant relatives of the victim.
With assistance from the FBI, detectives traced the family connections, interviewed relatives and obtained DNA samples for comparison. The process eventually established the victim’s identity as Fitzmaurice.
Authorities subsequently discovered that he had never been reported missing. Investigators learned that he had last lived with his wife and daughter at their family residence on Lichen Drive in Citrus Heights.
The sheriff’s office alleges that Mary Fitzmaurice killed her father at the family home and that she and her mother conspired to dispose of his remains. Detectives executed a search warrant at the Citrus Heights property on November 17 before arresting both women later that day.
Mary was booked into the South Placer Jail on murder charges, while her mother was booked on accessory charges.
The investigation received assistance from the FBI, Citrus Heights Police Department, Contra Costa County Crime Lab and Placer County Cold Case Foundation, which helped fund the DNA testing.
Authorities have not publicly established a motive for the alleged killing. The investigation remains ongoing, and the allegations against both women have yet to be resolved in court.
The case highlights how advances in forensic genetic genealogy can help investigators identify victims and reopen investigations that have remained unresolved for years.